Category: Sauropod

How the Brontosaurus Lost its Name

Ever wonder how the Brontosaurus lost its name? Commonly known as the icon of Sinclair Oil, this sauropod’s history is complex and newsworthy.

           The Brontosaurus is one of the most famous dinosaurs in the world. Millions of people know its name. Most can recognize its huge shape. It’s been on lunch boxes, made into countless toys, and was featured on a U.S. postage stamp. It even served as the official icon of Sinclair Oil company. However, there is one problem: there is no dinosaur named Brontosaurus.

           How did this happen? When dinosaurs were first discovered in the 1820s, the idea of those huge reptiles stalking the earth caught people’s imagination. Every museum in the world wanted to display a huge skeleton of a dinosaur. But it takes many years to find dinosaur bones, dig them up and put together a dinosaur skeleton. Over the next sixty years the competition to discover dinosaur bones grew, and then it became especially fierce during the 1880s. In fact, that time is now known as the “Bone War.”

           From 1877 to 1892, two paleontologists in particular, Edward Cope of the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia and Othniel C. Marsh of the Peabody Museum in Connecticut, were the fiercest competitors. They used their own money to finance expeditions and to buy dinosaur bones from other fossil hunters.

           In the beginning Cope and Marsh just paid collectors to send them fossils. But this was only the start. As the rivalry intensified, each side spied on the other, stole bones when they could, bribed workers, and even blew up fossils with dynamite so that the other side couldn’t get them. As soon as either dinosaur hunter got new bones, he rushed to get a description into print. Whoever publishes a description of a new dinosaur first gets to name it, and each man wanted to be the one to name the most. In the end Cope lost. He named 56 new dinosaur species, while Marsh named 80. And by the end of the Bone Wars in 1892, both men had gone nearly bankrupt trying to be the best (or most famous) paleontologist. And the hurry of both men led to mistakes.

Tadek Kurpaski from London, Poland, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

           In 1877 Marsh published a papernaming a new dinosaur, Apatosaurus ajax. Its name means “deceptive lizard,” which turned out to be the truth. The description was based on only a few bones. Two years later Marsh published another article describing what he thought was a different dinosaur, Brontosaurus excelsius.  This description was based on one of the most complete skeletons of a long-necked dinosaur ever found. Brontosaurus means “thunder lizard,” and the catchy name became popular. The mount of that Brontosaurus skeleton in the Yale Peabody Museum of Natural History increased its popularity. Unfortunately, one of the missing pieces of the skeleton was its skull. Not to worry. Marsh just put a Camarasaurus skull on it.

           But, in 1903, Chicago paleontologist Elmer Riggs took a look at both dinosaurs. He determined that the two dinosaurs were actually the same dinosaur. It was given the name Apatosaurus first, and the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature states that the oldest name has priority, so that is the name used by scientists. Brontosaurus became Apatosaurus. And in 1979 scientists finally put the right skull on the skeleton. Still, the general public didn’t let go of the name Brontosaurus until about the 1990s. It was just too cool a name to let go.

           However, all is not lost. There is a movement to resurrect the name Brontosaurus. In 2015 paleontologists studied hundreds of bones from Apatosaurus and the dinosaur called Brontosaurus and found differences in the neck, back, and shoulder bones. Originally scientists thought those difference were because one of the dinosaurs was a juvenile. Now some feel these differences are enough to say Brontosaurus and Apatosaurus are different dinosaurs. But this has not gained wide acceptance. More research may resolve the problem. But a lot of people who are just dinosaur lovers would welcome the return of the “thunder lizard.”

Cover Image Source: An Errant Knight, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why You Should Visit a Fossil Lab

            The best part of any museum is the dinosaurs– especially the huge skeletons! But they didn’t just walk into the museum on their own. And those bones weren’t always clean and perfectly shaped.

            In fact, the bones fossil hunters dig up are usually damaged in some way. They might have been chewed on by predators or scattered about by wind or water. They can be cracked, split, or smashed. So how do they go from broken to beautiful? This happens in a fossil lab.

            It starts with getting the bones safely back to the fossil lab. When a bone is dug out of the ground, sometimes it comes free easily. But more often the bone is attached to the rock, so fossil hunters need to carve out both. They use jackhammers and rock saws, pickaxes, hammers, and chisels.

            Scientists call the rock next to the bone the matrix. Fossil hunters leave the matrix around the bone, so it can protect the bone. They cover the bone and its matrix with plaster to provide more protection. The whole thing can weigh several hundred pounds.

            Small bones are packaged in crates while big bones may be lifted out by helicopter. They are all sent to a fossil lab. Unloading the bones must be done carefully. The big bones don’t always fit through the door. They need to come in through a loading dock.

            Some bones are stored away. There are always more bones needing preparation than time and people to prepare them. Bones not being worked on are put on shelves or in specimen cabinets.

            Other bones are brought into the prep lab to have the matrix removed from the bone. The workroom needs to have bright lights, so preparers can see what is rock and what is bone. It also needs good air flow because removing the matrix produces a lot of dust. Stations are set up around the room.

            A work station needs to have a large, flat surface to place the fossil on. There should be storage space for the tools the preparer will need and its own light source. It may also have a microscope to study small fossils and an air tube to vacuum up the dust and tiny bits of rock. The preparer should wear protective goggles, a dust mask, and gloves. Preparers using noisy tools, such as a jackhammer, also need ear plugs.

            When a bone is selected for preparation, first the preparers need to remove the plaster jacket. They use a cast-cutting saw, like the ones doctors use to remove a cast from a broken limb. A preparer might then use a small jackhammer called an air scribe to remove the matrix that is not too close to the bone.

            When preparers get close to the bone, they need to be very careful. The bones break very easily. Using a small metal pick called a pin vise (pictured to the side), preparers scrape away the rock, just like when a dentist scrapes plaque from your teeth. They scrape in a direction away from the bone so that if they slip, they don’t hurt the bone. The key is to go slowly. Sometimes they use a magnifying glass to make sure they are scraping away only the matrix.

            Bits of matrix are blown away with an air tube as they come off. Brushes can also be used to keep the surface clean, and a very sharp needle might be used to remove matrix in small cracks. Exposed bone is covered with glue to keep it from breaking apart.

            Sometimes preparers use chemicals, such as acid, to dissolve the matrix, but they must be careful to make sure the chemicals don’t hurt the bone. It can take anywhere from a few minutes to hundreds of hours to remove all the matrix. Sometimes part of the matrix is left to hold delicate bones together.

            Once the matrix is removed, there is still work to be done. Often the bone is broken, so the pieces must be put together. That can be like putting a jigsaw puzzle together. Very small bones can be kept together with wax. Others need glue, and others need wire or steel bands.

            Putting together all the bones of a skeleton takes lots of patience. Preparers make sketches and 3-D models. Bones need to be placed next to each other in the same way they were when the dinosaur was alive. A natural-looking pose must be chosen.

            It is rare that fossil hunters find all the bones for one dinosaur. Preparers need to figure out which bones are missing. To complete the skeleton, preparers may use bones from several dinosaurs of the same species. Sometimes they can figure out what a bone should look like by the bones around it. Then preparers can sculpt a bone from plaster or plastics.

            Many of the prepared bones are stored in cabinets or lockers. They each have a number that tells when and where the fossil was found. Scientists can find the fossil they need and study it.

            Sometimes the scientists make a cast of a bone. First, they make a rubber mold from the real bone. Then they put plaster or resin into the mold. When it dries, it’s a perfect copy. Museums often display casts rather than the real bones. This prevents damage to the real bones and makes it easier for scientists to study the real bones. Casts are also used to make model dinosaurs. Artists create realistic-looking dinosaurs for the movies or special exhibits. However, technology is already making this process easier and faster by using 3-D printing. In the future plaster casts will be a thing of the past.

            To prepare a skeleton for an exhibit, it’s important for preparers to make sure every bone is stable. Fossils are very heavy, so the framework holding them up needs to be able to hold the weight without hurting the fragile fossils.

            The bones are held together with such things as glue, metal pegs, bolts, wire, and thick cables. The preparers try to keep these out of sight because they want the dinosaur to look as natural as possible.

            It can take several years to mount a big dinosaur. But when it’s all done, thousands and thousands of people will gaze up at the dinosaur skeleton and catch their breath with awe.

            Would you like to work in a fossil lab? Please tell me why or why not in the comments section.

I took all the photos

What Was the Biggest Dinosaur?

            It’s almost impossible to declare that one dinosaur was the biggest of them all. Do you mean longest, heaviest, or tallest? Also, it’s very unlikely that paleontologists have actually found the biggest specimen of a dinosaur type. Millions and millions of dinosaurs once lived on Earth, and we’ve found only a small percent of them. We do know that all of the biggest dinosaurs are plant eaters. They come from the group of dinosaurs called sauropods, the long-necked dinosaurs – and most of the very biggest ones have been found in Argentina.

            So, how do paleontologists figure out how long or tall a dinosaur was? They need to look at the spine. Put your fingers on the back of your neck. The little bones you feel there that are part of your spine are called vertebrae. When a dinosaur skeleton is found, usually many of the vertebrae are missing. When there is a gap, paleontologists have to guess how many are missing. One way they do this is by comparing the bones they have to other, similar dinosaurs. If a similar dinosaur had, say, 80 vertebrae in its tail, paleontologists would assume that a closely related dinosaur had 80, too. But that might not be true. And it’s hard to know how big those missing vertebrae would be. Scientists have to make the best estimate they can, but they often don’t agree with one another. However, they have provided some great contenders for biggest dinosaur!

Longest:

Danny Cicchetti, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

            This might be Barosaurus (BARE-uh-sore-us). It was discovered in 1889 in South Dakota. Its name means slow, heavy lizard, and it must have been. Scientists think it was probably 82-89 feet long. That’s long, but that’s not what put it in contention for longest. Scientists have found a huge vertebra that they think belonged to Barosaurus. From the size of it, the creature it came from was likely about 157 feet long! That’s almost as long as three eighteen-wheeler trucks set end to end.

Nobu Tamura (http://spinops.blogspot.com), CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

            Another contender is Argentinosaurus (are-juhn-tee-nuh-SORE-us). Scientists have only found 13 of its bones: a few ribs, some vertebrae, and a five-foot-long femur (thigh bone). This isn’t much to try to figure out  how big this dinosaur was, but the sizes of those bones have led scientists to estimate that Argentinosaurus was between 75 and 100 feet long. If that top limit is right, Argentinosaurus is definitely among the very biggest dinosaurs.

Heaviest:

User:Mariolanzas, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

            Argentinosaurus is also a contender for the heaviest dinosaur, but because estimates of its weight are based on so few bones, some scientists discount it. However, paleontologists have unearthed more than 200 bones of Patagotitan (PAT-ah-go-TIE-ton). These  bones were found in Argentina in 2012 and cause scientists to estimate that it weighed about 76 tons. The largest land animal today is the African elephant. Its top weight is seven tons. That means that Patagotitan weighed nearly as much as 11 elephants. And some scientists think at its biggest it weighed as much as 14 elephants.  

Nobu Tamura email:nobu.tamura@yahoo.com http://spinops.blogspot.com/,
CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

            Dreadnoughtus (dred-NOHR-tus) is a definite contender in weight. Its name means fearing nothing. And it’s hard to imagine any creature that it would have to be afraid of. It was discovered in Argentina in 2005.  Scientists have recovered almost half of its bones, so they are able to be fairly accurate in their estimates. They place its weight between 54 and 65 tons (though some scientists say that’s too high). It was also about 85 feet long and as tall as a two-story building.   

Tallest:

Levi bernardo, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

            Two stories, however, is not a contender for height.  The tallest dinosaurs reached close to the height of a six-story building, though again, it’s tricky to know for sure. Scientists don’t agree on how high up long-necked dinosaurs could lift their heads. Sauroposeidon  (Sore-uh-ps-SY-don) is certainly one of the tallest.
            It was found in Oklahoma in 1994 and named for the Greek god Poseidon. Poseidon could cause earthquakes, and it probably felt like this dinosaur could do that, too – just by walking. It probably stood just over 55 feet tall, which is, as it says above, almost the height of a six-story building.

            Patagotitan shows up again here. Depending on how it carried its long neck, it might have been as tall as a seven-story building. If it carried its head and neck low to the ground, straight out from its body, it’s a contender for longest dinosaur at 122-130 feet. The picture at the right shows Patagotitan at the Field Museum in Chicago

            Scientist do not agree which one was the biggest dinosaur. Other lists would include such dinosaurs as Mamenchisaurus (mah-MUN-chi-SORE-us), a creature whose neck was longer than the rest of its body, or Giraffatitan (ji-RAF-ah-TIE-tan), which had the same general build as a gigantic giraffe. We may never know which dinosaur was the biggest. But we can all agree that they were awesome!

            Which dinosaur do you vote for as biggest? Do you know a big dinosaur that isn’t in this list? Please leave your answers in the comment section.